Which tires are better, Kama or Belshina?

Content:

• About Belshina products
• About Kama tires
• Kama and Belshina: similarities and differences
• Prices for popular models Kama and Belshina
• What to choose: Kama or Belshina?
• Conclusion

High-quality tires ensure driving safety and minimize the risk of a car colliding with other vehicles and pedestrians. A competent choice of tires will give you a feeling of confidence on the road and provide comfort. Therefore, when buying winter or summer tires, it is worth considering numerous factors: brand reputation, wear resistance, speed index, load, elasticity, design features. If price plays an important role for you, you should pay attention to budget products from domestic manufacturers and brands from the CIS countries. The leaders in this segment are Kama and Belshina. We will talk about the difference between these tires and their similarities in this article. The presented review will help you choose the optimal type of car tires for the coming year and will allow you to save money on purchasing expensive imported tires.

The best all-season tires: reviews of manufacturers

Many motorists are skeptical about all-season tires. Some people prefer to use spikes in winter, while others prefer Velcro. Well, choosing a summer tire is a whole ritual for a number of drivers, especially those who like aggressive driving. We’ll talk about what the best all-season tires are and look at their key features.

An all-season tire should combine the qualities of winter and summer tires. That is why its compound is much more complex and expensive. Summer tires, for example, do not work at low temperatures, and winter tires at high temperatures.

It's all about the rubber mixture, which is designed for a certain temperature range.

As for all-season tires, the situation is somewhat different; they must effectively cope with the task regardless of the season and temperature outside.

However, there are still certain restrictions on use. Firstly, all-season tires can only be used up to zero temperatures and on cleared roads.

Therefore, using it for driving in snow is still impractical and dangerous. Although sometimes you have to do this. Of course, this type of tire is designed for use in slushy snow and does not become completely uncontrollable.

The best option is to drive on clean asphalt and at positive temperatures.

As for saving, all drivers are well aware that they can’t save money on tires, and they don’t need to do that. However, the budget segment is quite extensive. The main buyers of such tires are large companies with large fleets.

One of the popular models in Russia is the Kama-217 model. The tire tread pattern is very simple. There is a wide drainage channel in the center. The two central rows of tread blocks are quite large with cut lamellas.

The side checkers, unlike the central ones, are located at right angles.

It is worth noting that Kama all-season tires are a good choice for budget sedans of domestic production, where you can limit yourself to 13 or 14 wheel radius.

It should be noted that many motorists call these tires “wooden” due to the loss of elasticity when the temperature drops. There is also no need to count on any acoustic comfort while driving.

This tire is needed to get from point “A” to point “B” and nothing more.

All-season tires R16

Now let's look at tires in the mid-price segment. They are used by both commercial companies and ordinary drivers. Their price is more comparable to the quality of the product, and it’s not too expensive, while providing a certain level of safety and comfort.

Top model at an affordable price – Cordiant Off Road. These are all-season tires for SUVs, which can also be installed on passenger cars. The main advantage of this “Cordiant” is its wear resistance.

The tire can cover about 80 thousand kilometers, which is quite a lot.

It is also worth highlighting the following advantages of tires:

• high smoothness;
• the tread does not become clogged with stones and dirt;
• provides high maneuverability over rough terrain.

Such tires are most often used on Niva or Patriot cars. All-season tires for SUVs “Cordiant” are produced only for 15th and 16th radius with a maximum width of 275 mm. But when buying such tires, you should immediately forget about the silence in the cabin, and the car will consume a little more fuel.

Falken Ziex ZE-502

Many drivers have not even heard of such car tires. But if you look in more detail, this is a subsidiary of Continental. Looking at the reviews from motorists, it immediately becomes clear that the company maintains its brand. A large number of standard sizes (from 13 to 18 inches) make these tires stand out from their competitors. The minimum profile width is 185 mm.

Looking at the tread pattern, we can say that this tire is designed for daily driving on clean asphalt. It has virtually no side hooks.

This suggests that behavior on unpaved roads will be unstable. At the same time, the reinforced sidewall is practically not afraid of cuts, so you can safely drive onto the dirt road.

When buying all-season R16 tires, you can safely count on excellent handling and high durability.

Premium tires are usually installed on cars of appropriate quality. It is unlikely that anyone will buy expensive tires for the classic VAZ family. Take, for example, BFGoodrich Urban Terrain T/A - American top-end tires. The BFGoodrich company, with many years of experience, has proven itself well in the European and Asian markets.

If you don’t expect any supernatural qualities from budget tires, they drive and drive, then expensive ones should live up to your expectations.

I want it to stick to the road with every lamella and provide good handling. And the acoustic comfort should be at the highest level. But regardless of the price, it’s impossible to get everything at once.

So it is with this rubber, it has its strengths and weaknesses. The advantages include:

• high cross-country ability on soft soils and grass;
• efficient operation at low temperatures (down to -5 degrees);
• reinforced sidewall that is not afraid of stones.

But this tire also has certain disadvantages: it is noisy and expensive, and also does not brake well on clean asphalt.

This option will be especially interesting for hunters and fishermen, and simply for those who like to ride over rough terrain. The fact is that the compound is designed specifically for negative temperatures. Therefore, it can be used all year round.

Looking at the tire tread, you can understand that it is designed for off-road and snow driving. The asymmetrical tread pattern with large blocks and sipes does not become clogged with mud and snow.

Reinforced sidewalls are not afraid of impacts and cuts from sharp stones.

The Dunlop company produces two sizes - for 16 and 18 wheels. Not such a large selection, but there are options for width. The maximum is 285 mm.

It is worth highlighting the following advantages of the tire: excellent handling, thanks to a thoughtful tread pattern; remains soft even at sub-zero temperatures; provides high smoothness; relative acoustic comfort.

We can safely say that these are the best all-season tires for their price. The average cost of the 16th radius is about 6,500 rubles.

What do luxury cars choose?

We will now talk about the German company “Continental”, or more precisely, the ContiCrossContact LX 20 tires. They are rightfully considered the best of their kind. But the price tag fully corresponds to the quality.

A set of 20 tires will cost about 60 thousand rubles. Since the tires are all-season, the maximum permissible speed is about 210 kilometers per hour.

As for the standard sizes produced by the company, tires from R16 to R20 can be found on sale today.

The tread pattern is very complex. It consists of many small tread blocks, narrow and wide drainage channels and a large number of oblique sipes. It is noteworthy that the maximum load on one wheel of the ContiCrossContact LX 20 is 1285 kilograms.

This indicates that the tire is able to withstand high off-road loads. Overall, an excellent choice for daily driving on various types of road surfaces. The tires brake excellently both on asphalt and dirt roads.

Somewhat noisy after 70 km/h, but installing them on a business class car, this is unlikely to be noticeable.

If we consider the most popular manufacturers today, then several companies stand out from the rest. Judging by numerous reviews from motorists, the leader in the production of high-quality all-season tires for middle and business class cars is the Continental company.

Although such organizations as Dunlop and Hakapelita are also not lagging behind. The top models have the following positive qualities: predictable behavior at low temperatures, decent directional stability and acoustic comfort. But, according to many, they are not without their shortcomings.

For example, the Continental LX20 floats, but the Dunlops are too noisy.

But you need to understand that ideal tires do not exist. Therefore, you need to be guided by your needs, consumer reviews speak about this.

All-season tires with a radius of 14 or any other, depending on the region and driving style, are chosen in a variety of ways.

Therefore, it is impossible to say unequivocally that German or Japanese tires can solve all problems. Sometimes the Belarusian “BelShina” is quite enough.

What should you choose?

As noted above, much depends on the goals being pursued. If the task is only to travel short distances on clean asphalt, then you can choose budget tire options.

If, in addition to driving, you are also interested in comfort, then you should look towards models such as “Cordiant” or “Dunlop”. Of course, for rough terrain you need better and more reliable tires, the cost of which is much higher than “Kama” or “Kordiant”.

But this is definitely not worth saving on. Some things also depend on the transport used. Some cars cannot be installed with R13. Therefore, models such as “Belshina” or “Kama” disappear automatically.

But the all-season tire R16c from Continental is suitable for a modern budget sedan or even a crossover.

All-season is not for everyone

If we consider this type of tire as a separate type, then in terms of its parameters it is inferior to both summer and winter tires. But its main advantage is that it to some extent combines both types of rubber. There's no point in counting on savings.

Despite the fact that there is no need to buy a second set of tires and wheels, you will have to change the tires somewhat more often. Compared to summer tires, all-season tires wear out about 20% faster. But that's not all. The fact is that this type of tire is characterized by uneven tire wear.

Therefore, they must be rearranged periodically. Therefore, you shouldn’t expect much savings on tire fitting either.

But it’s still worth talking about a certain versatility of such rubber. If it is completely unsuitable for a harsh winter, since the rubber hardens at subzero temperatures, then for the transition period it is what you need.

For example, you can drive an all-season vehicle until the end of November and only then change your shoes. At the same time, you will be able to avoid long queues at the tire service. This also applies to the period when winter is not too harsh, but summer is hot.

In this case, you can install summer tires after the temperature reaches +20 degrees Celsius.

This type of tire is, without any doubt, very popular. This is especially true in large cities, where the roads are constantly cleared and you don’t have to drive through snowdrifts and ice. In such conditions, all-season tires are completely justified.

In other cases, it is better to purchase classic studs or Velcro, as well as a set of summer tires. Well, as for choosing a manufacturer, this is a personal matter for everyone, because sometimes too much depends on the available budget.

Therefore, some buy all-season tires 205 R14, and others R18.

Source: https://www.nastroy.net/post/luchshie-vsesezonnyie-shinyi-otzyivyi-o-proizvoditelyah

About Belshina products

Before answering the question “Which is better: Belshina or Kama?”, it is worth taking a close look at the features of each brand. Let's start with the Belarusian tire plant. Belshina produces more than 300 types of tires of different sizes for the following types of equipment:

• trucks and cars;
• minibuses;
• Agreecultural machines. Agreecultural equipment;
• road construction equipment;
• all-terrain vehicles.

The Belshina plant exports more than half of its products to Russia, and also has dozens of partnership agreements with other countries. The design and appearance of winter and summer tires of this brand have patent protection. At the same time, Belshina guarantees full compliance of tires with state standards. The tires themselves have a service life of at least 5 years and are suitable for use until the tread pattern is completely erased, as they retain their functionality for a long time. In addition to the fact that the tires are characterized by high durability, it is worth noting that they provide good grip on various types of roads, as evidenced by the results of various tests.

Which tires are better: Belshina or Kama?

High-quality tires are one of the main elements of safe driving.
A competent choice will give confidence that during sudden braking the driver will remain in control of the situation and will be able to avoid collisions with vehicles or pedestrians. Unfortunately, not all roads have an ideal surface, so when selecting tires, much attention is paid to wear resistance indicators. An aggressive atmospheric environment, road reagents, sudden temperature changes are factors that have a negative impact on car tires that should be taken into account when purchasing.

Belshina

The Belarusian tire plant "Belshina" is considered one of the notable production associations. About 300 types of tires roll off the assembly line for cars, trucks, agricultural machinery and road construction vehicles. The plant has business connections with dozens of countries; more than half of its output goes to Russia.

All tires of the Belarusian enterprise have patent protection for the main parameters - design and appearance . Belshina guarantees high quality products:

1. Full compliance of tires with state standards.
2. No defects arising during production.
3. Tire functionality, up to the maximum permissible wear of the tread pattern.
4. Service life is 5 years.

The tires meet all safety standards, provide reliable traction and are characterized by a high level of durability.

The diverse range of products produced by the plant allows you to select tires for the most popular vehicles:

• Agricultural machinery – walk-behind tractors, trailers, tractors, machines for field work and their attachments.
• Road construction equipment.
• Lifting and transport machines.
• All-terrain vehicles.
• Mining dump trucks.
• Cars.
• Minibuses and light trucks.

Innovative technologies, highly qualified employees and long production experience have enabled the plant to produce tires for any vehicle.

The Nizhnekamsshina production association operates under the auspices of PJSC Tatneft . The company occupies a flagship position among Russian tire manufacturers.

Tire production was launched in 1973, and within a couple of years the association began to lead the industry and receive awards for quality products.

The introduction of modern technologies into production has made it possible to improve the quality of tires and bring technical characteristics to international standards.

The Nizhnekamskshina Association produces tires for use in any climatic and road conditions - all-season, winter use, for difficult roads and quarry ones. The company's product catalog contains more than 250 items for various vehicles:

• Cars.
• Trucks.
• Agricultural machinery.
• Loaders.
• Dump trucks for quarries.

The company pays great attention to the issues of respect for the cleanliness of the environment. Modern treatment facilities have been put into operation that retain substances that can pollute the atmosphere. The production waste disposal system has been improved. Modernization of the technological process ensured economical energy consumption.

What common

Tires from Russian and Belarusian manufacturers are considered an excellent budget solution for motorists. Rubber production is carried out under strict quality control; products comply with state standards. Both manufacturers offer a wide range of models and are able to satisfy any needs of motorists.

In terms of such an important technical characteristic as wear resistance , Belshina and Kama have the same level of performance. Belarusian and Russian tires can easily withstand at least three seasons of active vehicle use.

What are the differences

Kama winter tires are capable of providing directional stability on frozen roads, ease of handling and cross-country ability in difficult cold conditions.

Belshina is inferior in winter characteristics. On ice and snowy roads, grip is weak and rolling resistance is low, which entails additional fuel consumption.

The braking distance of Belarusian tires on ice is catastrophically long.

All-season Belarusian tires have a lower noise level when driving at high speed than Kama. Kama tires create discomfort for the driver and are misleading due to the noisy hum.

What to choose

For regular city trips, Kama tires will be a good economical option. If trips to nature or to the country are added to city travel, then Belshina will be the best choice. Its technical characteristics will ensure safe and comfortable off-road driving.

Source: https://o-ladagranta.ru/kakaja-rezina-luchshe-belshina-ili-kama/

About Kama tires

When answering the question of which is better: Kama or Belshina, one cannot ignore the features of the domestic brand. The Nizhnekamskshina enterprise has existed since 1973 and, almost from the very beginning of its formation, regularly receives awards for the quality of its products. The Kama catalog contains more than 250 items for the following types of transport:

• cars and trucks;
• loaders;
• all-terrain vehicles;
• agricultural machinery;
• mining dump trucks.

The company produces tires for use in various climatic conditions; there are both winter and all-season tires, as well as tires for summer. In addition, the catalog also includes models for difficult roads. Kama pays special attention to maintaining environmentally friendly production and introducing innovations. Thanks to numerous unique developments, it was possible to bring the characteristics of our products into line with international quality standards.

Kama and Belshina: similarities and differences

If you really want to understand which is better: Kama or Belshina, it is worth studying the key characteristics of each brand. They have several common features and significant differences, which determine the features of choice for specific operating conditions.

Similar characteristics

Both Kama and Belshina belong to the segment of budget solutions. At the same time, rubber from both productions meets the highest state standards and is very durable. Tires from each of these brands will help you operate your car with confidence for at least three seasons. Another common feature that unites Kama and Belshina tires is a wide range of models. Each of these production facilities is capable of satisfying any consumer needs.

Differences

The difference between Kama and Belshina tires appears when comparing models of the same type. For example, domestically produced winter tires demonstrate more advanced characteristics than their Belarusian counterpart. A distinctive feature of Kama tires is directional stability, high cross-country ability in low temperatures, and ease of control. Belshina tires are inferior in terms of the quality of grip on snow and ice, and also lead to increased fuel consumption, since they are inferior in such an important parameter as directional stability. For summer tires the situation is diametrically opposite. In this segment, Belshina tires are superior to Kama tires. The latter do not hold up well on wet roads, and directional stability is noticeably lower than that of their Belarusian counterparts. Taking into account the fact that Russian models created for the summer have softer tires, sharp braking and rapid acceleration on them are not as effective as on Belshina. All-season tires from both brands have almost identical characteristics, except that the Kama is noisier.

Features of choosing tires: which is better - Amtel or Belshina

Many car owners take the choice of tires for cars quite seriously. This is explained by their desire to purchase high-quality rubber at an affordable price. That is why they often wonder which tires are better: Belshina or Amtel? In order to answer this question, it is necessary to consider the characteristics of tires.

Characteristics of winter tires Belshina

ATTENTION! A completely simple way to reduce fuel consumption has been found! Don't believe me? An auto mechanic with 15 years of experience also didn’t believe it until he tried it. And now he saves 35,000 rubles a year on gasoline! Read more"

Tires are produced from a high-quality rubber compound, which provides them with a high level of abrasion resistance and significantly extends their service life.

Thanks to the high-quality adhesion of tires to the road surface, a high level of safety is ensured while driving a vehicle. With the help of these tires, the stability of the vehicle on the road is ensured.

Despite the ability of tires to withstand heavy loads, they are rarely damaged, which allows you to save money on their operation.

Rubber 14 is produced from high-quality materials using a universal rubber mixture, which provides them with a high degree of wear resistance.

The company produces tires not only for cars, but also for trucks, which allows a person to choose the most optimal option for his vehicle.

Rubber 14 from this manufacturer is characterized by:

• Durability;
• Tenacity;
• Durability;
• Reliability.

Thanks to these characteristics, the highest quality level of grip between the tire and the winter road is ensured. Tires 14 have a fairly high block rigidity. This leads to improved braking and traction performance in icy road conditions. Due to the presence of deep channels between the blocks, the possibility of aquaplination in slush conditions is eliminated.

Belshina tires have bidirectional sipes, which ensures they have the highest quality traction characteristics. Thanks to the presence of a multi-row asymmetric tread pattern, the most correct behavior of the wheel on the road is ensured. By car you can fully move not only on icy roads, but also on snowy off-road terrain.

Features of Belshina summer tires

14 Summer tires are characterized by a special arrangement of grooves, which allows them to drain drainage water in the shortest possible time. This ensures that the hydroplaning effect is minimal even when the vehicle is traveling at high speeds. This tire is characterized by:

• Resistance to aquaplaning;
• Low noise;
• Environmental friendliness;
• Silence.

It is characterized by an environmentally friendly composition, which ensures safety during its use. Tires 14 adhere to the road surface with the highest quality, which allows you to drive a car in the summer in any weather conditions. The tires are characterized by excellent behavior even when driving on hot asphalt.

This rubber is characterized by maximum structural rigidity, which ensures the fastest possible response to various commands. Thanks to the use of innovative sipes, tire stability on the road is significantly increased.

Automotive rubber 14 is characterized by the presence of cooling ribs, which ensure a response to changes in road surface. That is why drivers do not notice discomfort and inconvenience while driving.

Thanks to the use of universal technology, the highest possible strength of the frame structure is ensured.

The design of the tread of automobile tires 14 is characterized by the presence of unique features, which provides the rubber with the highest quality self-cleaning.

Thanks to this characteristic, the vehicle can move on the ground.

The stability of tire 14 at high speed is ensured by the presence of stabilizers that are installed on the central rib.

Thanks to the universal development of the rubber compound, the tires are resistant to cuts and other negative mechanical impacts.

Thanks to these qualities, when using rubber on heavy vehicles, their service life is ensured.

Improved traction of the vehicle with the road is provided by wide polished grooves and an aggressive tread pattern.

Characteristics of Amtel winter tires

Rubber is characterized by the presence of deep grooves, the location of which is the shoulder part. With the help of these grooves, slush is effectively cleaned from the tire tread. In addition, this characteristic ensures the highest quality performance of the vehicle in off-road conditions.

The new rubber compound includes universal additives, which provides the car with a high degree of stability on the road. Thanks to this rubber, the process of driving a vehicle is greatly simplified. This rubber has the following qualities:

• Strength;
• Durability;
• Reliability.

Thanks to the excellent material used to make tires, they are able to maintain their quality even after long-term use. Thanks to the increased level of rubber strength, it can be used in the most severe winter conditions. The rubber is characterized by a reinforced steel cord breaker, which allows it to withstand the highest possible loads.

The tread is characterized by the presence of the most complex pattern, which ensures the highest quality grip on the road.

Also, thanks to the tread pattern, the angle that occurs when the wheel rotates is reduced. Such qualities of Amtel rubber provide the most comfortable car ride.

Tires are also characterized by the presence of run-in marks. They are eliminated after the rubber has covered the first five hundred kilometers.

When using tires, winter becomes nothing to them. This is due to the presence of sufficiently strong studs that ensure the vehicle’s stability in slush, snow or ice conditions. Thanks to the high level of resistance of automobile rubber, its excellent performance on any road surface is ensured, which is noted by many people.

The production of studs is carried out using universal technology, which provides it with anti-slip characteristics and also allows you to fully move in winter, even off-road. The center of the tenon is characterized by the presence of a flange with a tetrahedral body made of hard alloys. This stud design provides increased grip quality and a high level of stud stability.

Features of Amtel summer tires

Thanks to the versatility of these tires, a high level of vehicle maneuverability is ensured. Despite the excellent technical characteristics of rubber, its cost is quite low. The tires are characterized by the presence of reinforcement in the shoulder area, which makes them possible to use on a variety of vehicles.

Summer tires from this manufacturer combine only positive characteristics. Thanks to the use of universal technology during rubber production, low noise levels are guaranteed.

Reviews This brings many conveniences while traveling by car. When using this tire, the stability of the vehicle is ensured not only on wet roads, but also in light icy conditions.

That is why Amtel tires can be used in summer until late autumn.

The tires have special wear indicators. This allows the car owner to determine the expiration date of the tire. The tread blocks are characterized by a multi-ball arrangement and rounded corners, which ensures the highest possible acoustic comfort while driving a vehicle.

The tires of this automaker are characterized by a fairly developed drainage system, which provides the vehicle with a high level of resistance to aquaplaning.

To produce Amtel tires, the highest quality and updated composition of the rubber compound is used, which provides the vehicle with a high level of resistance on snow and ice.

Summer tires are characterized by:

• High-quality grip;
• Coherence of work;
• Stability;
• Sustainability.

The tire tread consists of four layers. To produce each of them, a special rubber mixture is used. Each layer works separately from other layers.

In this case, one layer is added to the other three. Thanks to the maximum rigid side part of the tires, the possibility of damage to the disk or tube is limited.

Tires are characterized by resistance to a variety of mechanical damage, which allows them to make full use of rubber.

Tire selection

It is impossible to say unequivocally which tire is better. This is explained by the fact that tires are characterized by the presence of their advantages and disadvantages.

For example, if we compare the noise performance of tires, then Belshina is better.

In terms of the quality of grip on the road surface, Amtel tires are better than their competitors, which ensures a high level of safety while driving a vehicle.

The tires have longitudinal sipes, which limits the possibility of aquaplaning. The Amtel manufacturer makes the slats a little deeper, which makes them better than their competitor. They are characterized by resistance to a variety of mechanical damage, which allows them to fully use rubber.

If we compare traction qualities, then it is necessary to give preference to Belshina tires, since they can be used not only on smooth road surfaces, but also off-road.

In terms of road grip quality, these tires are better than their competitors. They are much more confident when cornering.

This is explained by the highest quality rubber mixture, which is used for the production of car tires.

Car handling on snowy roads will be better when using Amtel tires. Despite this, the wear resistance of Amtel tires is better than that of its competitor.

These tires have reinforced shoulder areas, which allows them to be used mercilessly for 3-4 years.

Tires from both manufacturers can be with or without studs, which allows the car owner to choose the most suitable option for himself. Tires from both manufacturers are characterized by the highest quality.

It is quite difficult to determine the leader among the tires of these two manufacturers. This is explained by the fact that they are characterized by the presence of their advantages and disadvantages.

If there is a need to purchase tires, then the driver’s requirements are assessed. Both manufacturers produce tires with a directional tread pattern, which ensures high-quality drainage of water from under the wheels.

The choice of certain tires directly depends on the tasks that the car owner sets for them.

Tired of paying fines? There is a way out! Forget about fines from cameras! An absolutely legal new product - Traffic Police Camera Jammer, hides your license plates from the cameras that are installed in all cities. More details at the link.

• Absolutely legal (Article 12.2);
• Hides from photo and video recording;
• Suitable for all cars;
• Works through the cigarette lighter connector;
• Does not cause interference to radios and cell phones.

Source: https://kolesospec.ru/baza/kakaya-rezina-luchshe-amtel-ili-belshina.html

Prices for popular models Kama and Belshina

To make it easier to choose between tires from two brands, we suggest that you familiarize yourself with the retail prices for various models of each brand.

As you can see, Belarusian-made tires are slightly higher in price, although the difference can be called insignificant.